Why did Disney ruin Luke Skywalker

Star Wars 9: J.J. Abrams ruined the Skywalker saga

Ever since I saw the first trailer for Star Wars 9: The Rise of Skywalker, I've been skeptical that the saga's finale would satisfy me. Even though the return of Ian McDiarmid as Emperor initially euphorized me in my surprise, I felt deep inside me that episode 9 a failure would be. Because I knew: J.J. Abrams would be directing again.

Many of you will wonder what is the problem with that. After all, Star Wars 7, which Abrams previously staged, was well received by most fans. But for me he was that for a long time worst movie in the saga, until episode 9 came out. Because although individual elements like the last scene or the handling of Poe are very well done, The Rise of Skywalker is at least as generic, uncreative and ingratiating as the start of the trilogy.

J.J. Abrams dumped Star Wars 9 years ago

To explain why Star Wars 9 disappointed me so much, I have to go to the first Origin of many problems of the film. They are already in episode 7. With The Awakening of Power J.J. Abrams not wanting to go wrong. The prequels by George Lucas were downright hated back then and it looked like the Lost co-creator didn't want to rekindle the anger of Star Wars fans.

Star Wars 7: The Force Awakens

It's understandable. Unfortunately, that made him look too much like the original trilogy. Episode 7 has its strengths, like the exciting new characters around Rey (Daisy Ridley) and Kylo Ren (Adam Driver), and J.J. Abrams managed to bring the look and feel of Star Wars to the next generation. Yet the plot of the film is desperately uninspired.

J.J. Abrams didn't use the potential of Star Wars 7

After the fall of the Empire and the victory of the rebels in Return of the Jedi, it would have quite a few possibilities given to continue the history of the galaxy in an interesting and logical way. A power vacuum was created that had to be filled.

Star Wars 6: Return of the Jedi

The Emperor's death, for example, could have drawn out a number of previously oppressed factions to claim rule for themselves, while the former rebels would have tried to build a new democratic republic. Another war could have erupted and Luke and Leia would have noticed that peace in the galaxy is not that easy to establish. A conflict between many different fronts would have been an exciting new direction for the franchise.

That is only one of many possible variantshow Star Wars could have gone on. But J.J. Abrams opted for an unimaginative solution that made little sense in the overall context of the previous films.

Star Wars 7 is an uninspired and illogical film

In Star Wars 7, the empire simply returns. Sure, it's called First Order now, the stormtrooper helmets look different and the Starkiller Base is technically not a Death Star, but let's be honest: How unimaginative is that? The worst thing about The Force Awakens starting position isn't even that Lack of ideasbut the lack of an explanation of how it came about in the first place.

Star Wars 7: The Force Awakens

After all, the First Order has one incredible amount of resources and members. Where do they come from so suddenly? No matter how sympathetic and well-played the heroes are, no matter how fascinating Kylo Ren and BB-8 are no matter how cute. If the world around these characters seems like a bad joke, there is no serious conflict that can be conjured up.

J.J. Abrams got on with all of this nostalgic brackets the role models overlook the fact that he cannot simply copy the political starting point of episode 4. There is, after all, an entire trilogy that explains how Palpatine came to power. The three films before episode 7 ended in triumph for the rebels. That the first order is so powerful in the sequels seems inconsistent. Imagine if in Revenge of the Sith the Jedi had won and in the next part everyone would still be dead.

Rian Johnson is not to blame for the Star Wars debacle

With Star Wars 8, Rian Johnson created the most interesting and best part of the new Star Wars trilogy, but he was also able to do it Failure of the trilogy not prevent. Abrams' successor was so focused on making a good film on its own that he had no consideration for its predecessor or successor. That can be criticized, but if Abrams had made a not so uninspired start, Johnson would not have had to take such drastic measures.

Star Wars 8: The Last Jedi

The last Jedi had already anticipated the climax of the trilogy. Kylo Ren eliminated Snoke like Darth Vader once eliminated the Emperor in Episode 6, albeit one movie too early. The parallelism of the actions of the two trilogies has been removed. With Kylo Ren as only remaining villain the story took a surprising and exciting turn.

A difficult initial situation that a courageous and capable author can still unite reasonable conclusion could have brought. But J.J. Abrams, who wrote the script with Chris Terrio, was just the wrong person for the job.

Star Wars 9 harms the entire Skywalker saga

Instead of looking ahead, the Star Wars 9 director once again makes use of the familiar and already fetches it requested palpatine from the moth box. The fact that he is once again showing off his lack of ingenuity is the slightest problem. Because with the survival of the Emperor, the grand finale of Return of the Jedi also loses importance.

Star Wars 9: The Rise of Skywalker

The prophecy that Anakin would destroy the Sith is only fulfilled when Darth Vader sacrifices himself to kill Palpatine. That moment has had one since Star Wars 9 pale aftertaste. We now know that the Emperor survived. This knowledge will change our perception of the scene forever. J.J. At least Abrams could have had the decency to reasonably explain the Sith Lord's return, but he doesn't even try.

From the beginning, Abrams put the sequel trilogy on a problematic foundation. But with Star Wars 9 and the Emperor conjured up from the hat, he even made it to the entire Skywalker saga to deteriorate afterwards. J.J. Abrams always played it safe. Ultimately, he did more harm than good to the distant galaxy.

What do you think of J.J. Abrams as a Star Wars director?