Who was worse Voldemort or Umbridge

The real reason Voldemort wasn't the worst villain in Harry Potter

Warner Bros. PicturesBy Nina Starner / .20. April 2020 2:37 p.m. EDT

In the magical world of Harry PotterIt's pretty clear from the start that Voldemort (played in the Ralph Fiennes film franchise), born Tom Marvolo Riddle, is the main antagonist. After the Dark Lord tries to kill Harry Potter (Daniel Radcliffe) as a baby to reverse a prophecy that predicts that Voldemort will fall into the hands of the child, he spends the next decade hiding. But as his enemies predict, he will come back stronger than ever.

During his time at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, Harry - the 'Boy Who Lived' - has to wage war with Voldemort every year. The ongoing feud culminates in his seventh and final year at Hogwarts when Harry and best friends Ron Weasley (Rupert Grint) and Hermione Granger (Emma Watson) at the age of 17 sought to destroy Voldemort's Horcruxes in order to finally destroy the Dark Wizard's soul can be killed once and for all.




Whether you've read the books a million times, watched the movies over and over, or done both, you probably think it is VoldemortHarry Potteris the worst bad guy - but you could be wrong about that. While Voldemort is a terrible, vengeful and cruel mass murderer, there is someone arguably worse than him: Professor Dolores Umbridge, played in the films of Imelda Staunton. Umbridge is a senior department official who will do everything for personal benefit and professional development. He's the worst person in the world Harry Potter Series, mainly because it presents itself as a hero.

Here's why Umbridge - and not Voldemort - can be considered the worst villain in Harry Potter.

Dolores Umbridge betrayed her own family

Warner Bros. Pictures

J.K. Rowling, who wrote the original Harry Potter In the book series it was pretty clear why she created the character of Umbridge in the first place: She didn't want the concept of "evil" to be completely black and white. She expresses this through Sirius Black (played in the films by Gary Oldman), who in Harry's fifth year tells his godson that the world is not simply divided into absolutely good people and nefarious Death Eaters - which makes it clear that bad people can also work for seemingly virtuous purposes like the Ministry of Magic.



In an essay on Wizarding worldRowling recounts how Umbridge attacked her own family in an attempt to succeed in the magical law enforcement division. She hated her father for his lack of ambition in the Ministry and eventually had him fired and lied about her Muggle mother to seek pureblood status. As Rowling relates, anyone who asked about Umbridge's family would suffer an accident or calamity and show how far Umbridge would go to cover up their true parentage or the fact that their father was a janitor at the Ministry.

Umbridge's unique brand of evil

Warner Bros. Pictures

Published elsewhere in her essay on Dolores Umbridge Wizarding world, J.K. Rowling stated that she based Umbridge on a real character in her own life who she strongly disliked and who also donned pink, childish, and girlish outfits that seemed to directly contradict her true nature. However, Rowling made it clear that the fictional Umbridge is in a completely different league when it comes to sadism and violence. She even noted that Umbridge's heinous acts are on par with Voldemort's: "Your desire to control, punish, and inflict pain in the name of law and order is as reprehensible to me as Lord Voldemort's unvarnished advocacy of evil."

Even Umbridge's name reflects how terrible she is as a person: 'Dolores' means grief, something that she undoubtedly causes all around her,' wrote Rowling. 'Umbridge' is a play about 'umbrella' from the British expression 'take umbrella' which means 'insult'. Dolores is offended by any challenge to her limited worldview; I felt her last name convey the pettiness and rigidity of her character. '



Compared to Voldemort, who makes no attempt to disguise himself as a good person, Umbridge is a villain who poses as a hero. She's the wolf in sheep's clothing, and that's why she's so terrible.

Attending Hogwarts during Professor Umbridge's tenure was pure torture

Warner Bros. Pictures

Readers and viewers meet Dolores Umbridge for the first time in the fifth episode of the series. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenixwhen she takes a job as Hogwarts' Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher - when she's actually there to keep an eye on Albus Dumbledore (Michael Gambon) and the way he runs Hogwarts on behalf of the corrupt ministry . Although Umbridge speaks to her students in a sickly sweet, simplistic-looking voice to pretend she's a friendly, comforting presence, she quickly reveals her true colors.

Some of Umbridge's worst acts include belittling centaurs (and any creature that is not fully human) and participating in the attempted murder of a centaur, humiliation of Professor Trelawney (Emma Thompson), and delighting in Trelawney's pain as her tried to evict her from her home. actual child abuse and, of course, denying that Voldemort has reappeared - putting the whole world at risk.

With Umbridge recreating the completely wrong narrative, Voldemort has actually not returned from Harry's fifth year - which he did certainly Has - Harry immediately stands by her during her first Defense Against the Dark Arts class and boldly tells the truth. As a result, Umbridge sentenced him to prison, but their detention poses a much more challenging challenge than Harry ever expected. While Harry keeps writing 'I won't tell lies', Umbridge's special pen cuts the sentence into his skin. Thanks to this punishment, Umbridge is the only person besides Voldemort who permanently marks Harry's skin.

Like everyone else watching the Defense Against the Dark Arts teachers, Umbridge only met for a year, but unfortunately she shows up at the Ministry during that time deathly Hallowswhere she adds up Muggle-born wizards and accuses them of 'stealing' magic. Though she ultimately spends time on her crimes, she still ends up going down as one of the worst villains in the wizarding world.

If you have to relive Umbridge's worst moments, it appears in the fifth and seventh Harry Potter Movies and books, though we can't imagine why you'd want to.